Monday, March 06, 2006

Kirby Puckett 1960-2006

I've argued elsewhere that Kirby Puckett was the most fearsome hitter to dig in against the Mariners in my lifetime. Yes, Barry Bonds, or Alex Rodriguez, and even Mark Texeira were *better* hitters, but Puckett was the guy who filled you with dread. And it's not just because of that sickening line-drive off the cheek of the M's Steve Shields (a game I attended as a kid... i'm still amazed that Shields survived, and yet I still feel like pointing out that the M's won it in the ninth).

This is tough to fully explain to people who weren't around for Puckett's reign of terror; it was because, not in spite of, the fact that he wouldn't walk. There are a hundred sabermetric reasons why he wasn't the 'best' player of the 1980s, but man, there's no one I hated seeing more than Kirby. He hit .414/.469/.759 in seattle in 1986, and then followed that up with a .500/.520/1.042 (no, that's not an OPS - that's a SLG percentage; seriously) line against the M's in 1987. See what I mean? It's not enough that he beat you - he actually made you root for him while doing it. I didn't think that was possible to replicate, until Pedro Martinez came along. There are players whose performance transcends rooting interest - and while that's a pretty damned high bar to get over, Kirby was one of the few to do so.

For all those that complain that his OBP wasn't what it should be, I submit that you're missing the point entirely. Not only did he have the demonstrated ability to take out a promising young M's pitcher, but he also had the ability to change a game, no matter what the score. Not only was he a lifetime .830+ OPS hitter - he was getting better just before his eye injury: he was a 900 OPS hitter for his last two years. There's a reason so many people went nuts for Edgar Martinez: there wasn't a better *right handed hitter* in the game except Puckett. No righty had won a batting title since Carney Lansford, who, if you're wondering, never provoked anywhere near the same time of reaction. I expected Mike Morgan, Matt Young, Pete Ladd, Lee Guetterman to get Lansford out. I was pleasantly surprised when they got Puckett out.

He's justifiably famous for his 1991 world series exploits against the Braves: this is the sine qua non of a star player willing his team to victory. I have no idea how to measure what Puckett meant to that 1991 Twins squad, but I will say that he captivated this neutral observer, and millions more like him.

Rest in peace, Kirby.

2 Comments:

At 3/07/2006 12:11 AM, Blogger PositivePaul said...

My senior year in high school (man, I'm reminiscing a lot about school today, aren't I) I worked for a Health Food company up in Federal Way. One of my coworkers was from Minnesota, and sung the National Anthem before several Twins games. Being a bit of a baseball fan back then (though less so than I am now), I was fascinated to find out she'd dated Kirby Puckett. It rather surprised me to find out that off the field he had, well, issues back then, as I'd always considered him a positive guy.

His case for the HOF is a curious one, in that while I do believe he was a good hitter -- an All-Star caliber hitter that was nearly at the top of the league every season -- and while he absolutely destroyed the Mariners, he was a borderline choice for the Hall. I definitely would've thought Mattingly would've gone in before Kirby did. However, he was one of the most feared right-handed hitters, and obviously had enough credentials to make it into Cooperstown. I'm just hoping the same applies when it comes time for Edgar's eligibility. Kirby's one of those guys who probably helps Edgar's case.

One more thing, though. I'm certainly not one to criticize people for their behavior -- I have no right to do that. That his his parents died fairly young, and two of his siblings died at 50 and 46, had to be active in his thoughts. And, I wonder how any of us would respond to life if one day we were not only living our dream, but being practically on top of the world, and then, literally the next day -- waking up not able to see, and having it completely knock us off that mountain. That had to have a devistating effect on Kirby's psyche.

When I heard this news, my heart literally sank. I'll admit to being pretty saddened by this news. I'm sad for his fiance. I'm sad for his ex-wife and two children. I'm sad for Twins fans and former teammates and coaches (and those from other teams who played against him). I'm sad that baseball lost one of its greatest today.

 
At 3/07/2006 9:30 AM, Anonymous Rain Delay said...

My heart sank when I returned home from work and fired up the computer. Kirby was a true baseball hero. Though it is a bit annoying that Sports Center keeps running his Homer against the Braves to force Game 7 in the 91 WS.

Oh and you guys got a mention over at Deadspin.com about this very Kirby write up.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home